Is it fair to perceive those who are poor in English as less competent?

6x4---

“The story published by Times of India (dated January 5, 2014) triggered these questions and worth giving a thought which says fluent English speakers earn 34% more than others do.”

– Dr. Raj

Follow Dr. Raj on Twitter @drraj29

 

Do we actually perceive some one to be less competent if he/she speaks poor English? Is it possible to hide functional incompetence behind confidently spoken English? To what extent the HR tools and managerial assessments go beyond the poorly spoken English and test the competence to perform the job? Is English proficiency a threshold competence and a base criterion

is your english good enoughWhile some of the roles demand English to perform the job, there may be some roles where English may not be required to perform the job, but it still influences how one is perceived at work place. The story published by Times of India (dated January 5, 2014) triggered these questions and worth giving a thought. It says fluent English speakers earn 34% more than others do.

  • Is it fair to perceive someone as less competent due to poor English?
  • Is the managerial judgment influenced by the English proficiency?poor in english as less competent
  • Are the competence assessment tools unfairly rating those who are poor in English?
  • Is it true that those who are in poor in English need to work harder to prove their worth functionally? 

Follow us on Twitter @hrfootprints

Related Posts

25

Feb
Blog, HR Consulting

7-Parameters for Building Performance-Oriented Organizations

As a strategic HR partner, we are about to complete two performance cycles using a performance management system that we designed and implemented at one of our manufacturing clients in 2019.  From a stage of people’s reluctance to the process to voluntarily asking us when are we initiating the goal-setting process, has been yet another phenomenal journey […]

23

Feb
Learning and Development

Behavioral Training for Managers/ Supervisors is not an option but the need of the hour- Part 2

Continuing to the first part of the blog, let us discuss the next three key aspects. ROI of such an Initiative Often companies complain of talent shortage, lack of skilled resources, cost of selecting – hiring, and onboarding a resource. All this can be significantly saved if you train the resource for the right skill set. Overtime[…]